#2 Unless the one I got was a dud I would avoid this one. It dried out super fast and you can never get the ink to actually come out of the tip. Terrible for fine details and does not last all day. Look elsewhere.

I love the lancome liner. A wonderful product that is long lasting and results gives you beautifully sexy eyes. My husband loves my eye makeup. Next I want to try Dior liner. I've great things about it. Have a nice day :-)

These are all pretty pricey. The drugstore has some great dependable liquid liners as well.

I love lancome liquid eyeliner. I use the lancome eye lash primer& lancomes hypnose drama mascara and my eyes look so sultry and sexy.

The Kat Von D eyeliner stays put for hours! Very pigmented, very long wearing. Such a high quality product, I recommend it if you need your eyeliner to stay on!

The Guerlain has been my go-to for years!! Well worth the money ❤️

1 is my all time favorite!

I also use the sephora brand liquid eyeliner in black and teal and it looks really sharp!

Benefit cosmetics has a good liner can't remember the name but it's great too for drugstore I like the maybelline liner two thumbs up 👍👍