Buyer Beware: Makeup Brands That Are Bad for Your Skin ...

Buyer Beware: Makeup Brands That Are Bad for Your Skin ...
By Eliza • Apr 5, 2024 MD

There are so many brands of makeup on beauty store shelves. That can make it hard for a girl to know whether she should buy Maybelline or CoverGirl. Both of those brands are some of my go-tos. What about you? You’d think that big name brands like these would be the ones you should gravitate toward, but they aren’t the best in many cases. That being said, anytime a brand of makeup causes a reaction on your skin, you should quit using it. Here are some to be especially aware of.

1. Maybelline

Many reviewers have condemned Maybelline for their mascaras. It’s usually because they don’t stay put and end up under their eyes. When this happens, not only does it mess with your look, but it also leaves that residue on your skin, which can result in breakouts for some people. If it works for you, go for it! If not, Maybelline is probably a brand you can skip.

***

Despite the brand's popularity and affordable prices, Maybelline's foundation range has also come under scrutiny. Some users report experiencing porer clogging and breakouts, especially with the heavier formulas intended for full coverage. Moreover, if you are someone with sensitive skin, you might want to steer clear as their products might contain fragrances or other irritants. Always patch-test before committing to a full face application and consider exploring other brands that prioritize non-comedogenic ingredients if Maybelline's offerings don't mesh well with your skin.

Thinking...

Please leave your email and we’ll get back to you on that.

2. Milani

I don’t have a ton of experience with this brand, but it doesn’t get very high ratings from reviewers. Many say that the cover-up products don’t work well and leave skin patchy and blotchy looking. You don’t want that, do you? Having to reapply all the time is a total bummer and some users say the product leaves their skin itchy.

Thinking...

Please leave your email and we’ll get back to you on that.

3. CoverGirl

This one totally surprises me! I’ve used a variety of CoverGirl products my whole life and have only ever had problems with the purple and pink ones because the dye causes my skin to react in a big way. Other users say that the TruBlend products don’t work as well as they are supposed to, they are disappointing, and they make skin feel weird and itchy.

***

While some faithful aficionados swear by CoverGirl for their budget-friendly cosmetics, those with sensitive skin might want to steer clear. There is chatter about certain foundations causing breakouts, and complaints about the scents being overwhelming and potentially irritating. It's a classic case of your mileage may vary—while one person may bask in the glow of their LashBlast mascara, another might be nursing red, watery eyes. Always patch test if you're diving into new territory, because even old favorites can sometimes turn on you.

Thinking...

Please leave your email and we’ll get back to you on that.

4. Revlon

Testers of Revlon lip products say that they don’t come close to living up to their reputation. Apparently, they are supposed to taste good, go on smooth and provide long lasting coverage. Many users say this isn’t the case and that the products aren’t worth the money they cost. When a lip product leaves you uncomfortable and dried out, you should probably make a switch.

Thinking...

Please leave your email and we’ll get back to you on that.

"Enhancing your beauty doesn't always mean going for the glossy look. More ladies now see the allure of a shine-free finish. With the right tools and techniques, you can also achieve a flawless, subtle glow. Learn how to master this trend by following these incredible matte makeup tutorials. Enhance your natural complexion without the unnecessary flash."

5. Sally Hansen

This is a pretty affordable brand, but many customers are horrified at the results. According to those who tried the primer, it doesn’t do anything to help keep make-up in place and makes skin feel oily and gross. Many of the Sally Hansen products are said to wear off too soon. You definitely don’t need that!

***

Sally Hansen is a popular drugstore brand, but it has been getting negative reviews from customers. Many have complained that the primer does not help keep makeup in place, and makes the skin feel oily and gross. Additionally, the products are said to wear off quickly, so customers don't get their money's worth. It is important to be aware of the potential risks of using makeup brands that are not good for your skin. Researching customer reviews and ingredients can help you make an informed decision when it comes to choosing the right makeup for your skin.

Thinking...

Please leave your email and we’ll get back to you on that.

6. Neutrogena

According to users, many of the Neutrogena skin products are not effective and don’t provide the coverage they are supposed to. Others say that they have to use a large amount of the product for it to work like it should. That means you run out faster and have to spend more to purchase another tube.

***

Despite Neutrogena’s reputation for mild and nonirritating products, some customers have experienced adverse reactions such as breakouts and redness, suspecting that the formulas are not as gentle as marketed. It’s also concerning that certain reviews have highlighted the inclusion of potentially harsh ingredients that could strip the skin of its natural oils. Users with sensitive skin, in particular, should approach these products with caution and perhaps seek out alternatives that are better tailored to their specific skin needs.

Thinking...

Please leave your email and we’ll get back to you on that.

7. Rimmel London

One of the products from Rimmel London that gets the worst reviews is the concealer. Users say that it won’t stay where it’s supposed to and slides right off your blemishes. Other products wear off too quickly and need reapplication several times each day. That sounds like reason enough to put them down, doesn’t it?

Do you love any of these brands? If they work for you, don’t worry about what reviewers say. Use them whenever you want. Do you have any other brands to add to the list?

Feedback Junction

Where Thoughts and Opinions Converge

  • Reggie

    2015-05-17T12:07:05.585Z

    Not all true. You just have to know what to put on your face. And be open to use other product which can give you the result u want.
  • Allyfedor

    2015-05-17T12:30:34.975Z

    I think these products will have different results for different skin types. Plus most people only put up a review if they are unhappy, so it might seem like it's not a good product, but it's really not in general.
  • Jennette

    2015-05-17T16:29:18.887Z

    This is a disappointing article. It only faults drugstore brands, and doesn't present a
  • Taylor

    2015-08-04T02:16:58.261Z

    Misleading article. What works for some may not work for others.
  • Adria

    2015-05-17T13:00:22.487Z

    all brands have good and bad reviews. this article could have listed any makeup brand and said the same exact things. pretty pointless list.
  • Heather

    2022-06-20T09:13:44.816Z

    I haven't used many Milani products, but have tried their bronzer which was just so so, and don't think it's horrible or anything. I'd have to try more to give a fair review.
  • Tink68

    2015-05-17T12:41:03.306Z

    They all have harmful chemicals in them! I use Honeybee Gardens, and Pacifica which have natural ingredients in them.
  • Eeaster

    2021-09-03T00:02:28.607Z

    #1 I loooove Maybelline and I don't agree with this at all. (PERIOD)
  • Jennette

    2015-05-17T16:37:00.835Z

    This is a disappointing article. It only faults drugstore brands, and doesn't present any actual research that these brands use bad ingredients for skin. I have used high-end products that were terrible. It just depends. There will be bad apples in every brand, whether drugstore or department store. For the record, I love all these brands and have continued to use them for years.
  • Megan

    2015-07-01T08:14:49.363Z

    So I guess L'Oreal is good then?
Commenting as

Keep exploring

Search AllWomenStalk for your next read.

Add allwomenstalk.com as a preferred source on Google to see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
Allwomenstalk app icon

Don't Miss the Latest Version

Get the latest stories, save favorites, and share with friends — all in one place.

New Earn badges & level up while you read

Create your profile. Earn badges. Level up your reading.

Join Allwomenstalk to track your streaks, collect badges, and earn XP for the things you already do—reading, sharing, and taking quizzes.

  • 🔥
    Daily streaks with gentle boosts for 3, 7, and 30 days.
  • 🏅
    Collect badges like Reader I–III, Socialite, and Quiz Ace.
  • ⚡️
    Earn XP for reads, deep reads, likes, comments, and shares.

It’s free. Takes 30 seconds. Already have an account? Sign in.

10,000+ badges earned last month

Level

3

Streak

7 🔥

XP420 / 700

Badges

🔥 On a Roll
📖 Reader I
📣 Socialite

Trending products

Other Cool Reads

Related Topics

most expensive product at sephora tend skin dupes gym toiletries for her best cruelty-free makeup brands best beauty box signs you're not photogenic sephora travel shampoo colormates compact makeup why is elf so cheap makeup items every girl needs
Featured article image